An analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america

In modern practice, the electoral college is mostly a formality most electors are loyal members of the party that has selected them, and in 26 states, plus washington, dc, electors are bound by laws or party pledges to vote in accord with the popular vote although an elector could, in principle, change his or her vote (and a few actually have over the years), doing so is rare. The united states electoral college is a body of electors established by the united states constitution, constituted every four years for the sole purpose of electing the president and vice president of the united states the college consists of 538 electors, and an absolute majority of 270 electoral votes is required to win election. America’s presidential election on november 8th shone a light on a quirk of its electoral system: the use of the electoral college rather than the popular vote to decide the winner.

The minority majority america’s electoral system gives the republicans advantages an electoral-analysis site, even if democrats won the national vote by six percentage points over a six-year. The founding fathers created the electoral college after much debate and compromise, but it has provided stability to the process of picking presidents though the winner of the national popular vote typically takes the presidency, that vote failed to determine the winner in four elections: 1824, 1876, 1888, and 2000. America’s presidential election on november 8th shone a light on a quirk of its electoral system: the use of the electoral college rather than the popular vote to decide the winner donald trump.

A 2016 npr analysis found that it's possible to win the electoral college with just 23 percent of the popular vote legislators in swing states such as florida, ohio and virginia have expressed little interest in joining the compact, for the obvious reason that those states receive a hugely disproportionate share of political attention, including events and advertising dollars , in presidential election years. Gore narrowly won the national popular vote, and many of his supporters howled that the system—even without the supreme court stepping in—was unfair one organization, national popular vote, has worked toward eliminating the electoral college through an amendment to the constitution or a state compact. Electoral college victory in 2020, even while losing the popular vote in many of the simulations that favor democrats in the electoral college, especially those beyond 2020, swing states that favored republicans in the 2016 election. With an expected win in the electoral college today, donald j trump will seal his presidential victory — despite losing the national popular vote by a significant margin.

- electoral college a major conflict concerning the electoral college lingers in america the constitutional convention created the college in 1789 in hopes that it would be an adequate system (macbride 29. It most certainly does not and i did an analysis myself to check why does the popular vote matter in america if the electoral college has the final say ask new question if the eu voted for a president, would they use an electoral college system or a popular vote. If the power of a single vote were calculated in terms of number of number of people per electoral vote, states like new york (519,000 people per electoral vote) and california (508,000 people per electoral vote) would lose.

But due to the “electoral college” system that america’s founders jury-rigged in part to square the needs of democracy with the demography of slavery, this does not hold true for america states vote in the college in proportion to their combined representation in both houses of congress. A us president is elected via the electoral college system it is not a building or institution, rather the college is really just a way to name a group of 538 people who are the formal electors. The last time a popular-vote loser won the presidency in the electoral college was, of course, in 2000, when george w bush edged out al gore 271-266 despite gore winning some 537,000 more popular votes nationwide.

An analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america

Electoral vote vs popular vote diffen social sciences civics in a presidential election, the popular vote simply means an aggregate of all voters from all states in america. If the electoral college is abolished, the compact terminates, according to the connecticut legislation criticism of the electoral college system has increased in recent years, after two presidential candidates — democrats al gore in 2000 and hillary clinton in 2016 — won the popular vote but lost the electoral vote. Stanford political experts say it is time to abolish the electoral college in favor of a single national popular vote where all votes count equally.

Most electors are loyal members of the party that has selected them, and in 26 states, plus washington, dc, electors are bound by laws or party pledges to vote in accord with the popular vote. Criticism of the electoral college system has increased in recent years, after two presidential candidates — democrats al gore in 2000 and hillary clinton in 2016 — won the popular vote but lost the electoral vote. Amar supports replacing the electoral college with a national popular vote, but he views the argument that electors should switch from trump to clinton because she won the popular vote as in effect changing the rules after the election. But that is less a product of the electoral college and more a product of the way states apportion electors in every state but maine and nebraska, electors are awarded on a winner-take-all basis so if a candidate wins a state by even a narrow margin, he or she wins all of the state’s electoral votes.

In the past, a clear majority favored amending the us constitution to replace the electoral college with a popular vote system donald trump secured enough electors in the electoral college to win the presidency, despite hillary clinton winning the popular vote. In the presidential elections of 2004, 2008 and 2012, the disposition of states in play meant that the democratic candidate would have won the electoral college had the national popular vote been. Calls to fundamentally change the electoral college reached a peak after republican george w bush defeated democrat al gore in the tightly contested 2000 election gore narrowly won the national popular vote, and many of his supporters howled that the system—even without the supreme court stepping in—was unfair.

an analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america However, commentators question the legitimacy of this national popular vote pointing out that the national popular vote observed under the electoral college system does not reflect the popular vote observed under a national popular vote system as each electoral institution produces different incentives for, and strategy choices by, presidential campaigns. an analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america However, commentators question the legitimacy of this national popular vote pointing out that the national popular vote observed under the electoral college system does not reflect the popular vote observed under a national popular vote system as each electoral institution produces different incentives for, and strategy choices by, presidential campaigns. an analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america However, commentators question the legitimacy of this national popular vote pointing out that the national popular vote observed under the electoral college system does not reflect the popular vote observed under a national popular vote system as each electoral institution produces different incentives for, and strategy choices by, presidential campaigns.
An analysis of the electoral college system and the popular vote in america
Rated 5/5 based on 34 review
Download