Japan was already defeated and dropping the bomb was completely unnecessary those are not the words of a latter-day revisionist historian or a leftist writer they are certainly not the words of an america-hater. Why were the atomic bombs dropped on japan featured instant articles news jun 8, 2016 george winston it is also a struggle to end an attitude toward human life that developed prior to world war ii years before hiroshima and nagasaki, british and american strategists proposed the burning of entire cities as legitimate methods to use.
Why was the atomic bomb dropped world war ii was an industrial war yes, there were men (and sometimes women) fighting men, but, it was primarily man and machine fighting man and machine the machines included: ships, aircraft, tanks, trucks, rockets, artillery, guns, trains, submarines, and electronics like radar, sonar and radio.
Home history articles were atomic bombs necessary to end world war two why then were atom bombs dropped on japan if dropping nuclear bombs was unnecessary to end the war, or to save lives, why was the decision to drop them made however, comes from top world war ii american military leaders the conventional wisdom that the atomic. Why then were atom bombs dropped on japan if dropping nuclear bombs was unnecessary to end the war, or to save lives, why was the decision to drop them made especially over the objections of so many t op military and political figures. The top american military leaders who fought world war ii, much to the surprise of many who are not aware of the record, were quite clear that the atomic bomb was unnecessary, that japan was on the verge of surrender, and—for many—that the destruction of large numbers of civilians was immoral most were also conservatives, not liberals adm.
Even while millions of americans continue to believe that the atomic bomb ended world war ii, many, including some in high positions in government and the military at the time, have long believed it was unnecessary.
Starting in the 1960s, the vietnam war left many questioning the ethics and necessity of war and led to the idea that the bombing of hiroshima and nagasaki were unnecessary economist gar alperovitz led a new group of historians to argue that the purpose of the bomb was to intimidate the soviets and not to defeat the japanese.
Truman made the decision to drop atomic bombs on nagasaki and hiroshima in august 1945 in order to put an end to the pacific portion of world war ii it is hypothesized that this was also a demonstration of power to the ussr, opening the cold war after germany's surrender in 1945, truman was faced. Even the official strategic bombing survey concluded shortly after world war ii that the atomic bombs were unnecessary: ''japan would have surrendered even if the atomic bombs had not been dropped.